Loading...
  OR  Zero-K Name:    Password:   

How much does this game cost ?

34 posts, 1925 views
Post comment
Filter:    Player:  
Page of 2 (34 records)
sort
I am curious to know exactly how much this game costs in case someone will be interested to buy it. Cost in a way where you will own all the game and the rights to develop it further. (not to play it, i know its free to play).
+0 / -0
1)you cannot buy gpl.
2)you mean like the sum of invested working hours of well trained code monkeys?
+3 / -0
"you mean like the sum of invested working hours? "
Anything is welcomed DErankAdminmojjj. I just want to know in numbers.
+0 / -0

8 years ago
DErankAdminmojjj, GPL is a license, but GPL license doesn't make any claims regarding the price of the software, covered by that license or whether it should be free as a beer or not.

Another question would be what does it cost to make the same game from scratch. And I guess it would be quite a lot in terms of money: springrts' code, ZK code, models, sounds, infrastructure, etc. My wild guess would be around $300k-500k for whole package and like around $50k-100k for ZK only part.
+0 / -0
Skasi
8 years ago
over 9000
+0 / -0


8 years ago
$5 to $80 less than other comparable games. The cost probably used to be higher (for the more powerful computer) but that seems to be fixed now.
+0 / -0
8 years ago
theres a statistics page somewhere which contains some of the numbers youre looking for, dont know where it is tho. as far as i recall, the amount of manhours put into zk is quite high and the cost would be a couple of millions if people would have been paid wages.
+1 / -0

8 years ago
https://www.openhub.net/p/springrts/estimated_cost
quote:

$ 8,576,140


https://www.openhub.net/p/Zero-K/estimated_cost
quote:

$ 16,277,670


This is exaggerated and wrong though, because the repository contains files like https://github.com/ZeroK-RTS/Zero-K/blob/master/LuaRules/Configs/REC_order.lua

And also because the model used to calculate the hours isn't similar to the standards in the game development industry.
+4 / -0

8 years ago
If some company would like to take over ZK development, they are free to do so, as long as they keep the game source code freely available, so taking ZK and developing it further

free, but taking ZK and not allowing anyone else to develop it further

illegal.
+2 / -0

8 years ago
Interesting numbers. I'm pretty certain that 4 people with 55 000 salary a year can replicate ZK in a year of 7-8 hours a day dedication.

$16M look so exaggerated. The company I work for was recently acquired for roughly $300M, however we had thousands times bigger code base, a hardware/software product line, hundreds of patents, paying customers all around the globe. I simply can't believe it's only worth 20 times more.
+3 / -0

8 years ago
quote:
I'm pretty certain that 4 people with 55 000 salary a year can replicate ZK in a year of 7-8 hours a day dedication.

No way. Uber honestly didn't produce more with PA, yet they certainly didn't have such small numbers.
+0 / -0

8 years ago
RUrankivand did you mean ZK alone or ZK+spring?
+0 / -0


8 years ago
quote:
Interesting numbers. I'm pretty certain that 4 people with 55 000 salary a year can replicate ZK in a year of 7-8 hours a day dedication.


ZK has evolved - that entails lots of duplicate effort and revisions. You could not compose ZK in a year, and you could probably only replicate it if you had the original to use as a guide throughout. RTS balance as fine tuned as ZK in a game as complex as ZK is as far as I am aware unmatched.
+0 / -0
I meant ZK alone obviously (more or less this https://github.com/ZeroK-RTS). Uber had to do a new engine + replace every non-GPL component Spring gets "for free".
+0 / -0
8 years ago
quote:
Cost in a way where you will own all the game and the rights to develop it further.
As I understand the licenses of spring & zeroK do not require you to pay anything. You can make your own versions and also sell it. And other people can do the same with your version.


I think problem with the cost-estimate-sites is that they assume every line of text to be unique lines written by full-paid programmer.
But one advantage of spring is that it does NOT require super-expensive skills for everything.
(Completly unexperienced people have learnt to write basic unit scripts or wupdgets within some weeks.)

Spring mods contain much text which imo is closer to "data entry" than "programming":
The definition files of units and wrecks/features, CEG (particle effects), stuff like https://github.com/ZeroK-RTS/Zero-K/blob/master/Anims/cursordefend.txt ,...
Something like "adding wrecks to all units" is many lines but after short introduction such tasks could easily be done by trainees.

Missions ( https://github.com/ZeroK-RTS/Zero-K-Missions/blob/master/sortale_ep3.mission.xml ) count as thousands of lines but are actually exported by editor.
Using missioneditor is of course also work but but different to 11.000 lines.

When remade from scratched some things could be done more effectively, too.
Ideally a commercial remake would have more clearer defined goal and be better organized, instead of more or less randomly growing.
Many dead ends would be avoided = faster development.
Beside engine, game itself & infrastructure one would also need some tools.
Though you could do without the outdated ones like 3DObuilder or Scriptor.

quote:
RTS balance as fine tuned as ZK in a game as complex as ZK is as far as I am aware unmatched.
Maybe, but I think balance is bit overrated. There is lots of changing and tweaking (still going on) but were the zK or CA versions from some years ago really unplayably bad? I think not.

Art is needed too.
I think in hobby this takes unusually long: People are 'learning while doing' or try out new techniques for the fun of it or get bored and take long breaks.
There is tons of videos by random youtubers who show it is possible to model & texture something complex in few hours. Imo CAD is similiar and ther I know this is to be possible too.
Not everything needs to be create inhouse by fulltime artists.
Generic 3D art (trees, rocks etc) can also be bought.

Same for audio effects, just get some soundpack.
Few dozen to hundreds dollars can buy art packages of very high quality.
For hobby that might be considered boring/lame but zeroK already uses art from many different sources.
For rather small price one can skip the whole "find something with suitable license" part and just get what is needed.


Yes, online RTS game, such wow, much project and everything, but realistically:
wikipedia says Planetary Annihilation had raised approximately $2,228,000 via Kickstarter and an additional $101,000 via PayPal.
That is with engine, with full original art, orchestral soundtrack and so on.

$16M for the game plus $8M for engine would put zero-k pretty close to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_most_expensive_video_games_to_develop
That seems way too high.
+3 / -0
8 years ago
The monetary figures are even less true because it doesn't count art assets mind you.

And imo the engine that Uber used to make PA is somewhat more capable than Spring. Did they produce more or less that is debatable. However adding in all major ZK and engine devs of the past and present we would actually have a bigger team than Uber.
+0 / -0


8 years ago
But Spring and ZK are hobbies - things people do in their spare time for their own satisfaction and enjoyment. That's a different metric to the work output of salarymen.
+2 / -0

8 years ago
With Spring, LUPS, Chili, Infra and similar it's probably doable in a year with 4 people, but I don't think you can ignore all that seeing as much of it was developed with ZK or very similar games in mind.
Without it, PA team/budget estimate seems about right.
+0 / -0

8 years ago
quote:

But Spring and ZK are hobbies - things people do in their spare time for their own satisfaction and enjoyment


stop romanticizing stuff, because:

quote:

[3:04 AM] Licho thats why i laugh when people here talk about "fun" developers have .. its bs, its hard work like anything else, fun might come later from outcome, but process is annoying. I prefer cleaning toilets to coding ZK

+1 / -0
If not enjoyment, then satisfaction. Why else would you work for free on any project, if you didn't feel that it was returning your investment in some way?
+2 / -0
Page of 2 (34 records)