Loading...
  OR  Zero-K Name:    Password:   
Map: Highway 95 West v2.1
 Highway 95 West v2.1
Title: [A] Teams All Welcome #2
Host: Nobody
Game version: Zero-K v1.11.6.0
Engine version: 105.1.1-1774-g5e966db
Battle ID: 1645228
Started: 18 months ago
Duration: 11 minutes
Players: 25
Bots: False
Mission: False
Rating: Casual
Watch Replay Now
Manual download

Team 1
Chance of victory: 44.1%

TWrankKitty116065
DErankmadez
FRrankSlaab
ITrankbinko
RUranklxa4000
NOrankskuggtheother
IErankSkuZzi
USrankSorcererYee
UArankandriuy000
unknownrankKobanous
FIrankEhal45
FRrankNailyk
PLrankpio903
Team 2
Chance of victory: 55.9%

GBrankBLaNKMiND
unknownrankFaynthasyn
USrankcabinboy
unknownrankaioeieoiao
CZrankpsaniac
DErankmuha_toro
NLrankEnderFrog
FRrankruru
PLrankGoldDeNas
USrankDiscountNinja
USrankyeeeet50
USrankjoegunter
Spectators
AUrankAdminGoogleFrog
FRrankZotsuh
USrankNobbester
BGrankDOGER
USrankBobdabuilder345

Show winners



Preview
Filter:    Player:  
sort
USrankcabinboy
18 months ago
(edited 18 months ago)
Due to a blue player resigning on gamestart citing his perception of balance, the highest rated blue player FRrankSlaab has to focus on two fronts at once due to the resigner being on the opposite side of the map. Tilt spiral ensues.

The resigner's perception stemmed from medal color, despite FRrankSlaab being a higher rank than two of the purples in this game.
+1 / -0
USrankNighthawk44
18 months ago
(edited 18 months ago)
This seems completely understandable, despite being a very not nice move to make. I think there is a moral advantage to the purple team even if the blue team is equally matched.

I'm still not sure why the balancer doesnt try to match by pair. Throw a purple on one team then add a purple to the opposite until you run out of purple players, then move to blue, to silver, to gold, etc. End result should be a relatively even mix of player rank and most importantly, both sides "feel" balanced.
+1 / -0
FRrankmalric
18 months ago
The color is not a good exact representation of skill it is just a hint (as here, Slaab is now position 14th in the ladder, while cbinboy and Blankmind are 17th and 18th).

And cmon, I have seen many games when people get balance "wrong" (myself included), so I find it a lame argument to quit.

There might be some improvement possible in how you compute rank changes including the play time - obviously in this game the rank of madez should not matter. I think that not including the time spent playing introduces various biases - another example if the player with smallest skill quits immediately that is an advantage for that team. AFAIK currently the time spent is not considered at all...
+0 / -0


AUrankAdminGoogleFrog
18 months ago
It was pretty lame.
+2 / -0

DErankmadez
18 months ago
When the player number is uneven, it's harder to balance and judge the balance of a match.
+0 / -0

DErankdunno
18 months ago
(edited 18 months ago)
quote:
The resigner's perception stemmed from medal color, despite Slaab being a higher rank than two of the purples in this game.


Maybe the new option to show precise ratings in the tab window should be enabled by default (to make balancer choices more understandable)?

To make it even clearer, the average rating of each team could be shown above or below (this is what the balancer tries to equalize. I've been developing an analysis of how wrong the use of the unadjusted average is in case of uneven player count teams, but should test it a bit more before posting).
+3 / -0


GBrankBLaNKMiND
18 months ago
SLAAB AND KITTEH ARE PURPLE IN MY EYES !

MAYBE I HAVE HUFFED TOO MUCH GLUE...

BUT I DOUBT IT !
+2 / -0