Loading...
  OR  Zero-K Name:    Password:   

Proposition : Dead doesn't vote

14 posts, 357 views
Post comment
Filter:    Player:  
sort
20 days ago
I propose that the teammates dead couldn't vote.

- Some people use "resign" as a way to force the game to stop. They resign if they want, but why stopping the others to game ?


- Some people resign but vote "no" when their still in-game mates want to quit. If they resigned, why forcing others to continue ?


- A lot of people don't pay attention to votes. That's particularly the case for "dead peoples". When there is a lot of dead peoples, votes often fail because not enough people pay attention.


I think only the people that are doing something in game should be allowed to vote if they want to stop or continue. Dead / resigned people don't play, they shouldn't decide for the others.



Now, if you excuse me, I have peanut butter to buy.
+6 / -0
20 days ago
I forgot to specify : I'm speaking about "will we resign" polls.
+0 / -0

20 days ago
Absolutely, those who resign shouldn't get to vote at all in the current match. Especially since they now see the whole map.
+3 / -0
changing this will result in at-least one single submerged duck hunt =D

maybe thats ok?.. but just keep in mind if the last living player wants to troll they will have impunity to drag a hopeless game into a watch me play bury me commander event..

if your ok with handing every player the power to hold games into existence then you may endeavour to do so.. but beware.. the power that you give them can and may be used against you one day for trolling
+1 / -0


20 days ago
Well you get the Overwhelming Advantage kicking in which makes hunting the last units pretty easy in the few cases it happens.

On the whole, I'm not sure it will shorten games or not.
Like sometimes, if the game lasts for a long time, lots of people might resign and do something else while waiting for the game end and while not caring to vote or watching the vote. In that case, it probably shortens already precluded games.
On the other hand, if someone is really stubborn and want to play the match out, they will be able to do that. Well the other players already resigned from the game, so why should they vote on the continuation, when they could, you know, go into another game room and try to start another battle in another lobby.

I find it annoying when people resign early just because they lost their lane and don't care about what else is happening on the map and just keeps voting to resign and start a new game. Sometimes games end way to early from that.
+6 / -0
20 days ago
Yeah, I can't deny that...
+0 / -0

20 days ago
If the last player wants to fight the enemy team, let them do that. It's their right. Let the better win. That some players don't know how to win or lose matches is an orthogonal issue.
+4 / -0


20 days ago
I would like to change to the OP. Specifically that dead teammates should vote as if they were spectators (ie for not very much).
+6 / -0
20 days ago
Well, you are the boss.
But I don't understand : What means "they shouldn't vote a lot ? Only at some type of polls ?"
+0 / -0

19 days ago
The big problem with this proposal is that it encourages even worse behaviour.

Someone is playing a game which they think is lost. They vote resign which doesn't pass. If they resign, they cannot vote anymore, so they don't wanna do that, so what will they do? Refrain from resigning and just idle their units, or play badly on purpose.

Of course people can also do that now, but at least now they have a voice despite the resignation, they have hope that the game will end soon.
+1 / -0


18 days ago
I think it is worse for players to continue to vote from the sideline when they can see the whole map than people refusing to resign just to keep voting to resign.
+4 / -0
18 days ago
dead men vote no polls
+0 / -0

18 days ago
I think it would be fine to remove a resigned player's ability to vote on resign polls. However, the vote count needed for team resign should be reduced accordingly. Otherwise you will get into a situation where the team wants to resign, but has to do it individually because they don't have enough living players to push it through.
+4 / -0
18 days ago
how often does a single player win a team game from a loosing position? i have never seen it happen
+1 / -0