I’ve had a few TAW games fall apart recently. I don’t want my games falling apart. I want each game to stay competitive for longer. I try to give feedback during/after the game, but there’s rarely enough time and it’s easy for people to take it as an attack. So instead of giving live unsolicited feedback, I’m going to put some observations here and try not to be so discourteous in-game.
Fundamentals #1. Front-line and back-lineThere are two broad categories of plays: front-line and back-line. If you back-line when you’re supposed to front-line, you’re gonna have a bad time. An individual player can switch between these roles many times in a game, but every action falls into one or the other.
A front-line action is one that takes or holds territory directly and reliably. When someone says “make units,” this is usually what they mean - units that contest or hold ground. They do not mean impaler, skuttle, merlin, or other specialised tools that are dependent on other units to defend them.
If you lose territory you were expected to keep, or fail to take territory that was easy to take, that is a front-line failure.
A back-line action is anything that does not directly take or hold territory. Knowing when these are appropriate is an important judgement skill; the whole team relies on people getting it roughly right. The simple test is: do you have both a reason and the space?
•
Reason: You can almost always invent a justification, but many back-line plays are shots in the dark. Because you are usually relying on teammates to cover while you do it, the play should actually be useful. Common unjustified examples:
1. Placing statics where they will never fire
2. Making pylons with no overdrive, or for things already connected
3. Making anti-air after scouting that they have no air
4. Making anti-nuke with no reason to believe they have a nuke
•
Space: If making the back-line play means you will lose control of territory you cannot afford to lose, you do not have the space. Look at the pressure on your sector, compare your fighting power to what is coming at you, and decide honestly whether you can spare the metal and attention.
In almost every TAW game there is more back-lining than the map can support. A lot of people want to do the interesting or high-skill thing before they have secured the “boring”, necessary thing. When in doubt, prioritise reliable front-line presence until the map is stable enough that the fancy play actually has room.
I often find it worthwhile to consider the player count, player skill, and map size/layout before deciding whether I’m predominantly front or back-line. For each lane, consider whether you feel confident it won’t just fold given who’s on the other team, and scout early to find out where the stronger players are so you can plan accordingly.