| 1 |
Well watching this game twice caused me to lose several brain cells, but a game with twenty-odd attempted kick votes seems like it needs a review.
|
1 |
Well watching this game twice caused me to lose several brain cells, but a game with twenty-odd attempted kick votes seems like it needs a review.
|
| 2 |
\n
|
2 |
\n
|
| 3 |
[b]West team kick of gjyvbts[/b]
|
3 |
[b]West team kick of gjyvbts[/b]
|
| 4 |
Whoever originally built the DRP nanoframe (can't remember who) gave it to gjyvbts by mistake. When the DRP finished gjyvbts did not control it. West team made what seemed to be a good faith attempt to communicate the issue to gjyvbts, then kicked them.
|
4 |
Whoever originally built the DRP nanoframe (can't remember who) gave it to gjyvbts by mistake. When the DRP finished gjyvbts did not control it. West team made what seemed to be a good faith attempt to communicate the issue to gjyvbts, then kicked them.
|
| 5 |
\n
|
5 |
\n
|
| 6 |
Getting
kicked
because
somebody
gave
you
a
unit
in
a
16v16
and
you
didn't
notice
seems
like
it
would
feel
pretty
bad,
but
there
is
enough
reason
for
this
kick
that
I
don't
think
it
is
appropriate
to
hand
out
modaction
over
it.
West
almost
certainly
loses
the
game
pretty
quickly
if
this
kick
doesn't
happen.
Maybe
it
should
be
harder
to
give
away
a
DRP
by
mistake.
|
6 |
Getting
kicked
because
somebody
gave
you
a
unit
in
a
16v16
and
you
didn't
notice
seems
like
it
would
feel
pretty
bad,
but
there
is
enough
reason
for
this
kick
that
I
don't
think
it
is
appropriate
to
hand
out
modaction
over
it.
Maybe
it
should
be
harder
to
give
away
a
DRP
by
mistake.
|
| 7 |
\n
|
7 |
\n
|
| 8 |
[b]East team attempted kick of waprold[/b]
|
8 |
[b]East team attempted kick of waprold[/b]
|
| 9 |
Kick vote was for not moving a Funnelweb to protect the DRP from incoming fire. Expecting a quite new player to understand what is going on and respond quickly 45 minutes into a 16v16 seems pretty unreasonable to me.
|
9 |
Kick vote was for not moving a Funnelweb to protect the DRP from incoming fire. Expecting a quite new player to understand what is going on and respond quickly 45 minutes into a 16v16 seems pretty unreasonable to me.
|
| 10 |
\n
|
10 |
\n
|
| 11 |
[b]East team kick of Felito[/b]
|
11 |
[b]East team kick of Felito[/b]
|
| 12 |
Felito sent a few constructors to reclaim the DRP wreck. He was told to stop by TheHiddenManiac followed by an immediate kick vote from Sodbuster on the basis of "teamkilling". Felito moved his constructors away and said that he would stop reclaiming. He was kicked anyway.
|
12 |
Felito sent a few constructors to reclaim the DRP wreck. He was told to stop by TheHiddenManiac followed by an immediate kick vote from Sodbuster on the basis of "teamkilling". Felito moved his constructors away and said that he would stop reclaiming. He was kicked anyway.
|
| 13 |
\n
|
13 |
\n
|
| 14 |
Reclaiming the wreck in this situation isn't really "teamkilling" in the first place, and Felito stopped when asked. This kick was clearly inappropriate.
|
14 |
Reclaiming the wreck in this situation isn't really "teamkilling" in the first place, and Felito stopped when asked. This kick was clearly inappropriate.
|
| 15 |
[spoiler]Sodbuster, Raptor42, Exterminador, Hvy, markivs, Zow, TheHiddenManiac, RedEagle_P1, Mirtille2[/spoiler]
|
15 |
[spoiler]Sodbuster, Raptor42, Exterminador, Hvy, markivs, Zow, TheHiddenManiac, RedEagle_P1, Mirtille2[/spoiler]
|
| 16 |
\n
|
16 |
\n
|
| 17 |
[b]TheHiddenManiac's attempted kick of therxxy[/b]
|
17 |
[b]TheHiddenManiac's attempted kick of therxxy[/b]
|
| 18 |
Somebody choosing to build a new Starlight rather than assist you in rezzing a DRP is not kickable. Pretty simple.
|
18 |
Somebody choosing to build a new Starlight rather than assist you in rezzing a DRP is not kickable. Pretty simple.
|
| 19 |
\n
|
19 |
\n
|
| 20 |
[b]TheHiddenManiac's attempted kick of Skender[/b]
|
20 |
[b]TheHiddenManiac's attempted kick of Skender[/b]
|
| 21 |
For reclaiming the DRP wreck (being rezzed, but not very fast) to put metal into the Starlight. I think in a situation where the team as a whole is clearly more on board with the build-a-Starlight plan, this is not kickable.
|
21 |
For reclaiming the DRP wreck (being rezzed, but not very fast) to put metal into the Starlight. I think in a situation where the team as a whole is clearly more on board with the build-a-Starlight plan, this is not kickable.
|
| 22 |
\n
|
22 |
\n
|
| 23 |
[spoiler]I also think that making the Starlight was more likely to win the game, for what that's worth.[/spoiler]
|
23 |
[spoiler]I also think that making the Starlight was more likely to win the game, for what that's worth.[/spoiler]
|
| 24 |
\n
|
24 |
\n
|
| 25 |
[b]therxxy's attempted kick of RedEagle_P1[/b]
|
25 |
[b]therxxy's attempted kick of RedEagle_P1[/b]
|
| 26 |
Spamming resign votes might be kickable in extreme situations but it does not seem to me that this was particularly extreme.
|
26 |
Spamming resign votes might be kickable in extreme situations but it does not seem to me that this was particularly extreme.
|
| 27 |
\n
|
27 |
\n
|
| 28 |
[b]Teamkilling[/b]
|
28 |
[b]Teamkilling[/b]
|
| 29 |
TheHiddenManiac reclaimed therxxy's Starlight nanoframe with Athenas (briefly) and Caretakers in retaliation for the DRP being reclaimed earlier. The Athenas moved back to rezzing the DRP but the Caretaker kept reclaiming. Skender then blew up the Athenas with some pylons. If the actively reclaiming Caretakers had been blown up we would be more understanding, but the Athenas were not at this time doing the team any harm.
|
29 |
TheHiddenManiac reclaimed therxxy's Starlight nanoframe with Athenas (briefly) and Caretakers in retaliation for the DRP being reclaimed earlier. The Athenas moved back to rezzing the DRP but the Caretaker kept reclaiming. Skender then blew up the Athenas with some pylons. If the actively reclaiming Caretakers had been blown up we would be more understanding, but the Athenas were not at this time doing the team any harm.
|
| 30 |
\n
|
30 |
\n
|
| 31 |
Instead of blowing up TheHiddenManiac's stuff he should just have been kicked, which indeed did happen a minute or two later.
|
31 |
Instead of blowing up TheHiddenManiac's stuff he should just have been kicked, which indeed did happen a minute or two later.
|
B1225217 32 on Fields_Of_Isis (Multiplayer)