| 1 |
Hi @[V]sheep, I want to express my opinion on the original premise.
|
1 |
Hi @[V]sheep, I want to express my opinion on the original premise.
|
| 2 |
\n
|
2 |
\n
|
| 3 |
I think there is no free-will. If free-will meant that we could make decision completely unrelated to what is happening to us and to our mind, then there is NO free-will. Every action have reason, and every reason have past reason, so it is impossible to have free-will. Things don't suddenly happen.
|
3 |
I think there is no free-will. If free-will meant that we could make decision completely unrelated to what is happening to us and to our mind, then there is NO free-will. Every action have reason, and every reason have past reason, so it is impossible to have free-will. Things don't suddenly happen.
|
| 4 |
\n
|
4 |
\n
|
| 5 |
When we talk about criminal and the law, IMO it change nothing. We always know that stuff happen because of a reason and there's always someone responsible for criminal action (either upstream-source person or unintentionally/side-effect of society). So, IMO it doesn't change anything.
|
5 |
When we talk about criminal and the law, IMO it change nothing. We always know that stuff happen because of a reason and there's always someone responsible for criminal action (either upstream-source person or unintentionally/side-effect of society). So, IMO it doesn't change anything.
|
| 6 |
\n
|
6 |
\n
|
| 7 |
I
believe
people
acknowledge
the
existent
of
free-will
because
the
phenomenon
is
apparent
to
our
own
perception
(
we
could
introspect
our
mind
and
test
it)
.
Free-will
also
make
sense
because
the
future
doesn't
really
exist
yet,
so
who
knows
what
going
to
happen
and
whether
it
happen
the
way
we
choose
it
to
be,
instead
it
will
happen
the
way
it
wanted
to
happen
irregardless
of
us.
If
free-will
meant
action
&
effect
have
no
reason
and
causes,
then
being
unable
to
effect
an
outcome
is
similar
to
the
universe
having
a
free-will,
thus
proving
the
free-will
exist.
|
7 |
I
believe
people
acknowledge
the
existent
of
free-will
because
the
phenomenon
is
apparent
to
our
own
perception
(
we
could
introspect
our
mind
and
test
it)
.
Free-will
also
make
sense
because
the
future
doesn't
really
exist
yet,
so
who
knows
what
going
to
happen
and
whether
it
happen
the
way
we
choose
it
to
be,
instead
it
will
happen
the
way
it
wanted
to
happen
irregardless
of
us.
If
free-will
meant
action
&
effect
have
no
reason
and
causes,
then
being
unable
to
effect
an
outcome
is
similar
to
the
universe
having
a
free-will
(
choice
doesn't
matter)
,
thus
proving
that
free-will
exist.
|
| 8 |
:P
|
8 |
:P
|
Free will