This game seems to be a victim of a lack of direction. I don't dislike the initial archer, but continuing to build archers after that lacks a clear purpose to me. More reasonable would be to pump out an archer to protect a conch, and then go straight for the island. The game plan here was... undirected? It fails the bad-plan-now test.

Also I don't like pushing on Tiba. There's no way they hold that position with 3 players on them, and I trade the archers I gave up a tempo for in order to accomplish something we'd do anyway. No point in going amphs if I'm going to fight like cloaks-but-dumb when there's a whole ocean to abuse. Ducks would be good here as well.

Notably, I misread the position as even when we each held an island, failing to note that Tiba actually held their island, our bronze did not.